Discover the best Italian restaurants in Buffalo with our top picks for authentic, delicious dining experiences in the city.
READ ALSO: Best spas in Buffalo, NY / Best florist in Buffalo, NY / Best places to stay in Buffalo, NY / Best sponge candy in Buffalo / Best Italian restaurants in Buffalo
Giancarlo’s
One of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants, Giancarlo’s serves authentic Italian food with great service and a cozy atmosphere. Due to its quality, authenticity, and enthusiasm for Italian cuisine, this family-owned restaurant in Buffalo has a dedicated following.
From the moment you enter Giancarlo’s, you know this isn’t just another Italian restaurant. Flavors come alive and every dish is carefully prepared. Rustic décor and soft lighting create a cozy atmosphere. The environment feels like you’re dining in a quaint Italian villa, making it the perfect setting for a romantic supper.
Giancarlo’s uses exclusively fresh ingredients, unlike other Buffalo Italian eateries. The menu celebrates Italian cuisine and offers something for everyone. From rich pastas to tender meats and delicious seafood, every item on the menu is made with the care of Buffalo’s top Italian restaurants.
Their bruschetta, made with toasted bread, tomatoes, basil, and olive oil, is a delicious starter. This meal showcases the restaurant’s fresh, local ingredients. Warm bread and fresh toppings create a harmonious balance that’s only the start.
Giancarlo’s spaghetti excels. Their house-made pastas, like lasagna and fettuccine alfredo, are the menu’s highlight. Lasagna is a filling dish with rich meat sauce, creamy ricotta, and well cooked noodles. Each taste recalls Italian cuisine’s slow-cooked, rich aromas. The fettuccine alfredo, with its creamy sauce and freshly cooked noodles, is a customer favorite.
Giancarlo’s meats and seafood are just as good as its pasta. Tender veal in crunchy breading, marinara sauce, and melted mozzarella makes the veal parmigiana stand out. The dish feels familiar and elevated, making it ideal for anyone seeking elegant Italian comfort cuisine. The restaurant offers flawlessly grilled scallops, shrimp, and fresh fish that accentuate sea flavors and Italian cooking.
Another reason Giancarlo’s is Buffalo’s top Italian restaurant is its pizza. Smoked wood-fired pizzas are served at the restaurant. The toppings are fresh and abundant, and the crust is thin and crunchy. Giancarlo’s pizzas are always delicious, whether you choose a margherita or a specialty.
Giancarlo’s wine list is noteworthy. A carefully selected collection of Italian wines complements the substantial meal. The wine list pairs strong reds and crisp whites with the food to improve the dining experience. The restaurant serves Italian-inspired cocktails like negronis and aperol spritzes that take you to Italy with every taste.
But Giancarlo’s service is what makes it special. The crew at this Buffalo classic goes above and above to make guests feel like family. The staff are knowledgable about the meal and wine pairings and always check in to assure your satisfaction. The attention to detail produces a dining experience that’s not only about the cuisine but about establishing a friendly place where people can relax and enjoy family time.
Giancarlo’s specializes at gluten-free alternatives and dish changes. This adaptability lets all guests, regardless of diet, experience Italian delicacies. The restaurant’s ability to satisfy a variety of tastes without sacrificing quality is another reason it’s one of Buffalo’s top Italian eateries.
Giancarlo’s hosts private parties and special events in addition to its regular menu. For small dinners or huge celebrations, the restaurant is ideal. Giancarlo’s is a great choice for Buffalo families and friends celebrating because the food and service are meticulously done.
Overall, Giancarlo’s is a must-visit for real Italian eating in Buffalo. Fresh ingredients, expertly cooked dishes, and great service make it one of Buffalo’s top Italian restaurants. Giancarlo’s has classic pasta, wood-fired pizza, and great meat and fish. It respects food and celebrates Italian culture and cuisine with every dish. Giancarlo’s is a Buffalo must-eat for memorable meals.
Osteria 166
For good reason, Osteria 166 is one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian eateries. This intimate, energetic restaurant’s blend of traditional Italian dishes and casual atmosphere makes it stand out in the city’s vibrant eating scene. Osteria 166 in downtown Buffalo is a local and tourist favorite for real Italian food.
Osteria 166 is known for its fresh, high-quality ingredients. The chefs here use locally produced produce, meats, and fish to make excellent, seasonal dishes. Classic Italian meals are updated with modern flair on the menu. Each meal is carefully prepared, with flavor and presentation in mind.
Osteria 166, one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants, makes its pastas in-house for the optimum texture and flavor. Everyone can enjoy a dish, from rich, creamy fettuccine alfredo to light spaghetti with fresh tomatoes and basil. Homemade pasta shines in dishes like ravioli, which are sometimes packed with fresh ingredients to bring excitement to the menu. Osteria 166’s pasta, whether bolognese or creative, is always unforgettable.
Another reason Osteria 166 is one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants is its pizza. The restaurant uses a wood-fired oven to make crisp, golden pizzas that can withstand hefty toppings of fresh cheese, meats, and veggies. The margherita pizza’s basic but tasty combination of mozzarella, basil, and tomatoes shows the restaurant’s dedication to Italian cooking. Sausage and peppers pizza, with flavorful sausage and nicely roasted peppers and gooey cheese, is a beloved indulgence.
Osteria 166 excels at classic meals and seasonal specials that showcase the chef’s creativity and experimentation while staying true to Italian traditions. This flexibility lets regulars discover new things each time they visit. Osteria 166’s wine list is meticulously selected with Italian and local wines to complement each dish. The skilled staff is happy to make recommendations, offering a tailored eating experience that matches the food.
The atmosphere at Osteria 166 enhances dining. Italian villa-style rustic design makes the house cozy. Exposed brick walls and soft lighting offer a pleasant ambiance for a romantic supper or family gathering. Our attentive and welcoming team makes customers feel like family at Osteria 166. The restaurant’s inviting atmosphere makes every meal feel special, whether you’re celebrating or just having fun.
Osteria 166 is one of Buffalo’s top Italian restaurants due to its consistent quality, not just its food and atmosphere. The restaurant’s founders and cooks aim to satisfy guests beyond the meal. Osteria 166 is a good choice for Buffalo Italian food due to its superb food, great service, and cozy atmosphere.
Many celebrate Italian food at Osteria 166: a passion for fresh ingredients, respect for heritage, and a commitment to crafting meals that bring people together. The restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it feels familiar and exciting to experience authentic Italian cookery. Osteria 166 dependably delivers a memorable dining experience in Buffalo, whether you’re ordering one of their famous pastas, a glass of Italian wine, or their wood-fired pizza.
Osteria 166 is routinely voted Buffalo’s top Italian restaurant. Anyone who enjoys Italian cooking should visit it for its fresh, high-quality ingredients, beautifully prepared dishes, and pleasant ambiance. Osteria 166 provides an unmatched Italian dining experience for Buffalo residents and visitors.
Frankie Primo’s +39
One of Buffalo’s top Italian restaurants, Frankie Primo’s +39, provides an authentic and memorable meal. This lovely city center restaurant blends traditional Italian cuisine with sophisticated technology. From the moment you walk in, the sophisticated, comfortable atmosphere creates the perfect setting for a wonderful lunch.
Frankie Primo’s success comes from sincerity. The cooks at this famous restaurant employ only the best ingredients, many of which are imported from Italy, to make each meal as authentic as possible. The restaurant’s name honors the founder’s family: “Primo” represents Italy’s emphasis on quality and family, while “+39” represents the country’s international calling code. The restaurant serves modernized Italian classics with a focus on authenticity.
Frankie Primo’s fresh pastas are a highlight. From handcrafted pappardelle to delicate gnocchi, the pasta is produced with care. These foods come with thick, savory sauces, such as aglio e olio or ragu. Frankie Primo’s is one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants due to its fresh pasta and well-made sauces. The seasonal menu lets diners try new flavors and fresh ingredients.
In addition to pasta, Frankie Primo’s has great steak and seafood. The restaurant serves delicate, melt-in-your-mouth osso buco and flawlessly cooked scallops to showcase Italian food. The kitchen crew meticulously prepares each meal, which has bold, balanced flavors and is elegantly presented. Frankie Primo’s has something for everyone, from classic veal parmigiana to more daring dishes.
Another attraction at Frankie Primo’s is its meticulously curated Italian wine collection from various regions. Wines that complement the restaurant’s cuisine are great for connoisseurs and casual drinkers alike. The skilled staff always recommends the perfect wine to suit your meal, enriching the dining experience.
But Frankie Primo’s service is what makes it special. Each client feels like family since the staff is attentive, friendly, and knowledgable about the cuisine. First-timers and regulars are always welcomed and respected. The restaurant’s friendly atmosphere, finely created food, and superb service reflect its dedication to offering a great dining experience.
For informal dining, Frankie Primo’s provides pizzas that rival Italy’s top pizzerias. The thin, crunchy crust and fresh, high-quality toppings make each pizza special. Frankie Primo’s pizza menu has something for everyone, from margheritas to creative creations.
Location in Buffalo’s lively Elmwood Village makes the restaurant convenient and appealing for diners. After eating, meander through the area or browse the shops for a fantastic evening out. Frankie Primo’s +39 is one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants because to its amazing food, great service, and prime location.
In addition to its usual menu, Frankie Primo’s offers specials and private dining, making it ideal for birthdays, anniversaries, and corporate occasions. From small groups to major celebrations, the restaurant’s personnel works with you to customize your experience. Every occasion at Frankie Primo feels special due to its intimate atmosphere and attentive service, solidifying its position as Buffalo’s premier Italian restaurant.
The commitment to quality, authenticity, and customer satisfaction makes Frankie Primo’s +39 one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants. The meticulously produced menu, excellent service, and appealing atmosphere are all aimed to transport you to Italy. Frankie Primo’s in Buffalo gives a flavor of Italy with fresh pasta, wine, and pizza. Frankie Primo’s +39 is a fantastic pick for Italian food lovers that never disappoints.
Salvatore’s Italian Prime
Salvatore’s Italian Prime in Buffalo is a standout restaurant that mixes Italian cuisine with modern elegance. One of Buffalo’s top Italian restaurants, this restaurant offers a memorable experience for people who want great food and a special atmosphere.
Salvatore’s Italian Prime isn’t your typical Italian restaurant from the moment you enter. The professionally decorated room and attentive staff provide a sophisticated yet pleasant atmosphere. A cozy atmosphere, exquisite décor, and gentle lighting enhance the eating experience. Salvatore’s Italian Prime’s environment makes for a memorable meal, whether you’re celebrating, having a romantic supper, or a family gathering.
The Salvatore’s Italian Prime menu honors Italy’s unique cuisine. The restaurant is one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants due to its high-quality ingredients and well-crafted dishes. Each meal is carefully made to retain Italian characteristics while using current techniques and inventiveness. The menu has something for everyone, from classic pasta to modern cuisine, making it a must-see for Italian foodies.
Salvatore’s Italian Prime’s pastas are notable. To assure authenticity and flavor, the restaurant makes its pasta in-house with the best ingredients. A rich, creamy fettuccine Alfredo or a wonderfully seasoned Bolognese sauce over tender spaghetti, Salvatore’s pasta is a tribute to Italian culinary excellence. The restaurant serves innovative pasta dishes with fresh seafood, seasonal veggies, and flavorful meats. Every bite has the depth of flavor and texture of Buffalo’s top Italian restaurants.
Wood-fired pizzas are another menu standout. The thin, crunchy dough and variety of toppings, from Margherita to exotic cheeses, fresh herbs, and quality meats, make these pizzas excellent. The smoky wood fire taste and fresh toppings make each pizza a standout that complements Salvatore’s Italian Prime’s other dishes. This Buffalo Italian eatery is a favorite for pizza aficionados.
Salvatore’s Italian Prime serves excellent meat, seafood, and Italian fine dining meals for people who prefer a more refined dining experience. The steak and veal dishes are very good, perfectly prepared to showcase their natural flavors. Each bite has a perfect combination of textures and flavors thanks to fresh herbs, strong sauces, and delicate garnishes. These dishes—a flawlessly seared filet mignon or a delicate veal chop—show the restaurant’s dedication to quality.
The wine list at Salvatore’s Italian Prime is another reason it’s one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants. The vast collection includes wines from Italy’s most famous areas and local and international selections. The staff is experienced and ready to propose wines that match the food. If you’re a wine enthusiast or a casual consumer, Salvatore’s wine list will enrich your dinner.
Salvatore’s Italian Prime is known for its attentive, competent, and professional service. Whether you need help choosing a cuisine or wine pairings, the team is always available. Salvatore’s stands apart from other restaurants with its attention to detail and focus to customer happiness. Salvatore’s is one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants because guests feel distinguished.
In addition to excellent food and service, Salvatore’s Italian Prime has delicious sweets to complete any meal. The tiramisu, with its light mascarpone, espresso-soaked ladyfingers, and chocolate powder, is a favorite. Rich chocolate tortes and creamy panna cotta are also delicious and complete the meal with a taste of Italy.
Catering options make Salvatore’s Italian Prime a popular choice for special parties. The restaurant’s customization and service ensure a successful corporate event, wedding, or casual celebration. Catering is a popular alternative for customers seeking a memorable dining experience outside of the restaurant because it shares the same quality and attention to detail as the restaurant.
As one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants, Salvatore’s Italian Prime serves delicious food, fine wines, excellent service, and a warm ambiance that keeps customers coming back. Salvatore’s offers a unique dining experience whether you want classic Italian food or something different. This restaurant is a major contender in Buffalo’s bustling culinary scene due to its dedication to quality and Italian food.
Trattoria Aroma
Trattoria Aroma is one of Buffalo’s top Italian restaurants, with a cozy setting that matches its original cuisine. This family-owned jewel in the city center is known for its traditional recipes, high-quality ingredients, and excellent service, making it a favorite among locals and travelers seeking authentic Italian cuisine.
From the moment you enter Trattoria Aroma, you feel at home. Exposed brick walls, hardwood tables, and intimate lighting create a pleasant, sophisticated atmosphere that makes guests feel at home. The setting is suitable for a casual supper with friends or a special event. The friendly staff makes you feel welcome, offers helpful advice, and ensures a wonderful experience.
Trattoria Aroma’s menu celebrates Italian flavors with innovative twists on classics. There’s something for everyone, from rich, creamy pasta to fresh, delicious seafood. This Italian restaurant uses only the best ingredients, setting it unique from others. Every bite tastes authentic Italian since each dish is carefully prepared. Trattoria Aroma takes pride in its cuisine, from its expertly seasoned sauces to its handcrafted pastas.
Daily-made pasta is a restaurant highlight. The rich, velvety pasta and flavorful sauces make each dish unique. A popular favorite is fettuccine Alfredo, with its creamy, rich sauce that coats the fresh pasta. To spice up your meal, try penne arrabbiata, with its soft pasta and spicy tomato sauce. Pappardelle with wild boar ragu is unique and must-try. The rich, delicious sauce complements the wide ribbons of spaghetti, making it luxurious and cozy.
Trattoria Aroma’s seafood is also noteworthy. Every taste shows the freshness of the ingredients. The branzino, a Mediterranean sea bass, is one of the most popular dishes because it is expertly seasoned and roasted to gold. The dish’s light, lemon-infused sauce and seasonal vegetables demonstrate the restaurant’s dedication to quality. The seafood risotto, full of shrimp, scallops, and mussels, is rich, delicious, and deep like Buffalo’s best Italian restaurants.
Wine is essential to any Italian meal, and Trattoria Aroma does not disappoint. Their wine range is meticulously crafted with Italian wines from diverse areas. Whether you like powerful reds or crisp whites, the educated staff can help you choose the right wine for your dinner. The restaurant’s beverages are made with the same care as their food. The Negroni, a classic Italian drink, is known for its bitter, sweet, and citrusy qualities.
Trattoria Aroma offers a rotating menu of specialties, giving diners different flavors and cuisines each time they visit. Diners can experience the finest produce, meats, and seafood with seasonal specials. The dynamic menu guarantees a fresh and exciting experience for weeknight dinners or special occasions.
But what makes Trattoria Aroma stand out from other Italian restaurants in the area is the personal touch the owners and staff put into every meal. The owners, who love Italian food, interact with customers to make them feel like part of the Trattoria Aroma family. The restaurant’s excellent food, friendly setting, and hospitality make it Buffalo’s best pick for real Italian dining.
Trattoria Aroma prioritizes quality in all aspects of its business, not just food and atmosphere. From the carefully sourced ingredients to the meticulous preparation of each dish, the restaurant values tradition and innovation. Trattoria Aroma is one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants due to its commitment to quality.
Trattoria Aroma offers the best of Italian cuisine and wine, whether you’re a longtime fan or new to it. Fresh ingredients, classic recipes, and a warm ambiance make it a must-visit for those seeking the city’s best Italian food. Trattoria Aroma is one of Buffalo’s greatest Italian restaurants, drawing customers from throughout the city for a delicious lunch.